| Date | Results | |
| April 18, 1996 | High Point Panthers 4, Coker Cobras 3 | |
| April 12, 1996 | High Point Panthers 7, Salem Spirits 0 | |
| April 10, 1996 | Pfeiffer Falcons 7, High Point Panthers 0 | |
| April 3, 1996 | St. Andrews Knights 6, High Point Panthers 1 | |
| April 2, 1996 | High Point Panthers 7, Lees-McRae Bobcats 0 | |
| March 27, 1996 | High Point Panthers 4, Barton Bulldogs 3 | |
| March 26, 1996 | High Point Panthers 9, Belmont Abbey Crusaders 0 | |
| March 23, 1996 | High Point Panthers 5, Erskine Flying Fleet 2 | |
| March 22, 1996 | High Point Panthers 5, Longwood Lancers 2 | |
| Marc 21, 1996 | High Point Panthers 7, Mt. Olive Trojans 0 | |
| March 14, 1996 | High Point Panthers 6, Catawba Indians 1 | |
| Feb. 27, 1996 | Guilford Quakers 5, High Point Panthers 2 | |
| Feb. 21, 1996 | High Point Panthers 4, Queens Royals 3 | |
| Feb. 19, 1996 | High Point Panthers 6, Gardner-Webb Runnin' Bulldogs 1 | |
| October 10, 1995 | High Point Panthers 5, Catawba Indians 2 | |
| October 9, 1995 | High Point Panthers 7, Lenoir-Rhyne Bears 0 | |
| October 3, 1995 | High Point Panthers 5, Methodist Monarchs 2 | |
| Sept. 26, 1995 | High Point Panthers 6, Meredith Avenging Angels 1 | |
| Sept. 22, 1995 | Catawba Indians 1, High Point Panthers 0 | |
| Sept. 20, 1995 | High Point Panthers 5, William Peace Pacers 2 | |